Many mothers have the "old fashioned" opinion about what a woman should be. The short story "Girl", by Jamaica Kincaid, is a prime example of this relationship.
Inexplicably, their devotion begins to crumble. No reason is given, and the reader is left to imagine the source of the trouble. Perhaps the mother is distracted by her relationship with her husband. In Lucy, Kincaid continues her examination of mother-daughter relationships, this time on two levels.
As the novel opens, Lucy has just arrived in New York to work as a nurse to the four young daughters of a wealthy family. In the succeeding months, Lucy watches the family, at first assuming it to be idyllic in its happiness.
At the same time, Lucy is carrying out a bitter battle with her own family, especially with her mother.
At home, as a child, she had carried out her rebellions secretly, by making friends of whom her mother would not approve and by experimenting sexually also in secret. She assumes that such behavior is the only way in which she can free herself from her past.
At last, she learns from a family friend that her father has died and that her mother is in desperate need of money. Lucy sends all of her savings to her mother, but she also writes her a bitter letter of rejection and accusation. When she later relents and writes a gentler letter, she includes a false return address, and she knows that her promise to go home soon is a lie.
Her descriptions of the island it is never actually named in Annie John and Lucy are full of exotic details about foods, plants, animals, and colorful local people. She describes the herb-laced baths her mother prepared for her and the stone heap in the yard on which white clothes were dried.
She refers to herb and magic doctors one of them, Ma Jolie, helps Annie John during a dangerous illness and to people who are possessed by evil spirits.
One critic has noted that Kincaid is uncompromising in presenting these pictures of a world that is quite foreign to most of her readers. She never explains or clarifies details; she never describes the island world in reference to North America. She approaches race in much the same way.
She never speaks to the reader as a writer of color; instead, her color becomes the norm. In the same way, she speaks as a representative of the people who have been colonized. The rulers and tourists, like the inhabitants of the middle-class world of the United States, are the outsiders.
Such problems, she implies, are the natural legacy of slavery and colonial rule. In Annie John and Lucy, Kincaid displays the same anger in fictional settings. Annie John, for example, reflects on a new schoolmate, an English girl, imagining that she must long to be in England, where she would not constantly be reminded of the terrible things her ancestors had done.Free Essay: Short story analysis of Girl by Jamaica Kincaid Have you ever wished that someone had given you a guide on how live the right way?
Jamaica. Essays and criticism on Jamaica Kincaid - Critical Essays. The power of Kincaid’s work seems to rise equally from her themes of family relationships and alienation, her use of detail to create. Thesis Statement. argumentative.
compare and contrast. log in × scroll to top. Home; A Literary Analysis of the Girl by Jamaica Kincaid PAGES 2. WORDS View Full Essay. More essays like this: jamaica kincaid, feminist perspective, the girl. jamaica kincaid, feminist perspective, the girl. Not sure what I'd do without @Kibin.
Ever wondered how Girl follows the standard plot of most stories? Come on in and read all about it. Skip to navigation Girl by Jamaica Kincaid. Home / Literature / Girl / Analysis / Plot Analysis ; Analysis: Plot Analysis.
BACK; NEXT ;. A summary of Themes in Jamaica Kincaid's Girl. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of Girl and what it means. Perfect for acing essays, tests, . Essays and criticism on Jamaica Kincaid - Critical Essays. Jamaica Kincaid American Literature Analysis Jamaica Kincaid.
Girl. Jamaica Kincaid. Lucy.